Best Smart Locks to Compare Before You Choose
The best smart locks are the ones that fit your door, match your phone and smart home setup, and keep ongoing costs predictable.
Contents
33 sections
-
What to compare before buying a smart lock
-
1) Door type and hardware: deadbolt vs lever
-
2) Backset and door thickness
-
3) Connectivity: Bluetooth, Wi‑Fi, Thread, Z‑Wave, or Matter
-
4) Access methods: keypad, app, key, or fingerprint
-
5) Security and durability basics
-
6) Subscriptions and ongoing costs
-
Best smart locks: named options to compare
-
Quick notes on these brands and ecosystems
-
Total cost of ownership: what it looks like with real numbers
-
Common cost categories to plan for
-
Three sample budgets (allocations that add up)
-
Scenario A: Basic DIY upgrade (total $250)
-
Scenario B: Remote access setup with add-ons (total $420)
-
Scenario C: Two-door household with pro install (total $850)
-
How to choose based on your timeline and priorities
-
Under 1 year (renters, short stays, temporary needs)
-
1 to 3 years (starter home, small family, frequent guests)
-
3 to 7 years (longer-term home, smart home buildout)
-
7+ years (forever home, durability focus)
-
Practical checklist before you buy
-
Security habits that matter more than brand
-
Use unique codes and remove them quickly
-
Turn on notifications that match your real life
-
Secure your accounts and Wi‑Fi
-
Keep a backup entry plan
-
When a smart lock purchase affects your budget or credit
-
Frequently asked questions
-
Do smart locks work during a power outage?
-
Will a smart lock lower my insurance?
-
Should I rekey when I install a smart lock?
-
How can I reduce the risk of identity theft if I am setting up new accounts?
-
Bottom line: build a shortlist, then compare the details that affect your daily use
Smart locks can be a practical upgrade if you want keyless entry, temporary codes for guests, or a better way to manage access for a rental or busy household. But they are also a purchase with hidden variables: door compatibility, Wi‑Fi requirements, batteries, subscription features, and the cost of rekeying or replacing hardware if something does not fit.
This guide walks through what to compare, named options to put on your shortlist, and how to think about the total cost of ownership with real numbers.
What to compare before buying a smart lock
Start with the basics that can make or break the install. A smart lock that is “best” on paper can be a poor fit if it does not match your door or your daily routine.
1) Door type and hardware: deadbolt vs lever
- Single-cylinder deadbolt (key outside, thumbturn inside) is the most common and the easiest match for most smart deadbolts.
- Mortise locks (common in older buildings and some condos) need specific models or adapters. Measure carefully.
- Lever locks (handle with latch) are a different category. Some brands sell smart levers, but many popular models are deadbolt-only.
Decision rule: If you are not sure what you have, remove the inside plate and take a photo of the bolt and the door edge. Compare it to the manufacturer’s compatibility page before you buy.
2) Backset and door thickness
Most U.S. doors use a 2 3/8 inch or 2 3/4 inch backset. Door thickness is often 1 3/8 inch to 1 3/4 inch, but older doors and security doors can vary. Smart locks often include adjustable parts, but not always.
3) Connectivity: Bluetooth, Wi‑Fi, Thread, Z‑Wave, or Matter
- Bluetooth: Usually simplest and battery-friendly. Remote unlock typically requires a bridge or hub.
- Wi‑Fi: Direct remote access without a hub, but can drain batteries faster.
- Thread: Low-power mesh networking often used with Apple Home and Matter. Usually needs a compatible border router (for example, certain smart speakers).
- Z‑Wave: Common in security-focused smart home hubs. Great for reliability, but you need a Z‑Wave hub.
- Matter: A newer standard designed to improve cross-platform compatibility. Verify which features work with your platform today.
Decision rule: If you want remote access without buying extra gear, prioritize Wi‑Fi models or Bluetooth models that include a bridge in the box. If you already have a hub, match the lock to your hub’s protocol.
4) Access methods: keypad, app, key, or fingerprint
Think about who uses the door and how. A keypad can be easier for kids, dog walkers, or guests. A physical key can be important as a backup. Fingerprint readers can be convenient, but performance varies by model and conditions (wet hands, cold weather).
5) Security and durability basics
Look for:
- ANSI/BHMA grade (where available). Grade 1 is generally the highest residential rating, but not every smart lock is graded.
- Auto-lock and wrong-code lockout settings.
- Tamper alerts and activity logs (some require subscriptions).
- Weather resistance if exposed to rain or direct sun.
Also plan for the non-digital reality: a smart lock does not strengthen a weak door frame. If your door jamb is flimsy, longer screws and a reinforced strike plate can help.
6) Subscriptions and ongoing costs
Some locks work fully without a subscription, while others place features like advanced notifications, video integration, or extended history behind a plan. Before you buy, check:
- Whether remote access requires a separate bridge or paid service
- How many users and codes you can create
- How long activity history is stored
- Warranty length and replacement parts availability
Best smart locks: named options to compare

Below are well-known smart locks that many shoppers compare. Availability and features can change, so confirm compatibility, current pricing, and platform support before purchasing.
| Option | Best fit | What to compare | Main drawback |
|---|---|---|---|
| Schlage Encode (Wi‑Fi) | People who want built-in Wi‑Fi and a keypad | Battery life, app features, voice assistant support | Wi‑Fi can mean more battery changes than Bluetooth-only |
| Schlage Encode Plus | Apple Home users who want Home Key | Home Key support, Matter/Thread details, availability | Can be harder to find in stock and may cost more |
| Yale Assure Lock 2 | Shoppers who want multiple configurations | Module type (Wi‑Fi, Z‑Wave, Thread), keypad vs key | Choosing the right module can be confusing |
| August Wi‑Fi Smart Lock | Renters or anyone wanting to keep existing deadbolt | Fit on inside of door, bridge needs, auto-unlock behavior | Bulkier interior unit and depends on existing lock quality |
| Level Lock+ | Minimalist look, keeping traditional hardware style | Compatibility, Home Key support, installation complexity | Less obvious keypad option, may require more setup patience |
| Ultraloq U‑Bolt Pro | People who want fingerprint plus keypad | Fingerprint reliability, bridge for remote access, weather use | Remote features may require add-ons depending on model |
| Kwikset Halo (Wi‑Fi) | Budget-conscious shoppers wanting Wi‑Fi keypad access | App experience, battery life, rekey options | Feature depth and app polish can vary by generation |
Quick notes on these brands and ecosystems
- Schlage is often compared for keypad reliability and mainstream support. Confirm which model you are buying because “Encode” and “Encode Plus” differ.
- Yale is popular with smart home users because of modular connectivity options. Make sure you choose the module that matches your hub or platform.
- August is frequently chosen when you want to keep the outside key cylinder unchanged, which can matter for rentals or HOA rules.
- Level is known for a subtle design that hides the smart components, but you should double-check door compatibility and desired access methods.
- Ultraloq is often shortlisted for fingerprint access, but compare real-world use cases like wet hands, gloves, and cold weather.
- Kwikset can be attractive if you already use Kwikset keys and want to keep keying consistent across doors.
Total cost of ownership: what it looks like with real numbers
Smart locks are not just the sticker price. Your total cost can include extra hardware, professional installation, rekeying, and ongoing batteries or subscriptions.
Common cost categories to plan for
- Lock purchase: varies widely by model and finish.
- Bridge or hub: may be needed for remote access or certain protocols.
- Installation: DIY can be free, but a handyman or locksmith adds cost.
- Rekeying: if you want all doors on one key or you moved into a new place.
- Batteries: most use AA or CR123 batteries. Frequency depends on Wi‑Fi use and traffic.
- Subscription: optional for some brands, required for certain features in others.
| Cost item | When it applies | How to control the cost | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bridge or hub | When remote access needs it (common with Bluetooth locks) | Buy a bundle or choose built-in Wi‑Fi | Extra device, extra outlet, extra setup |
| Professional install | If your door is misaligned or you do not want DIY | Measure first, choose standard door prep models | Old doors may need drilling or adjustments |
| Rekeying | New home, lost keys, or matching multiple doors | Choose rekey-friendly brands or plan rekey at install | Some smart locks have limited rekey options |
| Batteries | Always | Use quality batteries, enable battery alerts | Wi‑Fi models may need more frequent changes |
| Subscription | If you want advanced alerts, extended history, or integrations | Confirm what works without a plan before buying | Ongoing monthly cost can exceed hardware savings |
Three sample budgets (allocations that add up)
These examples show how a smart lock purchase can fit into a home budget. The numbers are illustrative, so check current prices, install rates, and subscription terms where you live.
Scenario A: Basic DIY upgrade (total $250)
- Smart lock (keypad model): $200
- Batteries and small tools: $20
- Contingency for door alignment parts (strike plate, longer screws): $30
Total: $200 + $20 + $30 = $250
Scenario B: Remote access setup with add-ons (total $420)
- Smart lock (Bluetooth model): $230
- Wi‑Fi bridge or compatible hub: $120
- Rekeying one cylinder: $70
Total: $230 + $120 + $70 = $420
Scenario C: Two-door household with pro install (total $850)
- Two smart locks: $500
- Professional installation (two doors): $250
- Annual subscription for alerts/history (optional): $100
Total: $500 + $250 + $100 = $850
How to choose based on your timeline and priorities
Smart locks are a home tech purchase, but you can still apply a simple decision framework that prevents overspending and reduces regret.
Under 1 year (renters, short stays, temporary needs)
- Prioritize: easy removal, minimal door modification, keeping existing exterior key.
- Good fit: retrofit-style locks (often installed on the inside only).
- Decision rule: If you might move soon, avoid models that require drilling new holes or buying multiple hubs.
1 to 3 years (starter home, small family, frequent guests)
- Prioritize: keypad convenience, reliable app, guest codes, auto-lock.
- Decision rule: If you host guests or have service providers, pick a lock that supports multiple codes and schedules without a paid plan, if possible.
3 to 7 years (longer-term home, smart home buildout)
- Prioritize: ecosystem compatibility (Apple Home, Google Home, Amazon Alexa, SmartThings), and a protocol that scales (Thread or Z‑Wave).
- Decision rule: If you plan to add sensors, lights, and security devices, consider a hub-based setup for reliability and fewer Wi‑Fi devices competing on your router.
7+ years (forever home, durability focus)
- Prioritize: build quality, parts availability, brand support, and a fallback plan if the app changes.
- Decision rule: Favor locks that still function well locally (keypad and key) even if cloud features change over time.
Practical checklist before you buy
- Measure backset and door thickness
- Confirm your door prep matches the lock (deadbolt vs mortise)
- Decide if you need a keypad, physical key, or fingerprint
- Confirm remote access requirements (built-in Wi‑Fi vs bridge)
- Check battery type and expected replacement frequency
- Review which features require a subscription
- Plan how you will manage access codes (naming, schedules, deletion)
- Set a small contingency budget for installation surprises
Security habits that matter more than brand
Most problems come from setup choices, not the logo on the lock. A few habits can reduce risk and frustration.
Use unique codes and remove them quickly
Create separate codes for each person or service. Delete codes when you no longer need them. This is especially useful for cleaners, dog walkers, and short-term guests.
Turn on notifications that match your real life
Too many alerts get ignored. Consider enabling only the notifications you will act on, like “door unlocked while away” or “multiple failed attempts.”
Secure your accounts and Wi‑Fi
Use a strong password for the lock account and enable multi-factor authentication if offered. Keep your router firmware updated and use a strong Wi‑Fi password. For broader identity and account protection practices, the FTC has practical guidance at https://consumer.ftc.gov/.
Keep a backup entry plan
Know how you will get in if batteries die or your phone is unavailable. That might mean carrying a physical key, keeping a spare with a trusted person, or using a keypad model with a low-battery warning.
When a smart lock purchase affects your budget or credit
Some shoppers finance home upgrades with a credit card, buy-now-pay-later plan, or a small personal loan. If you are considering borrowing, compare the total repayment cost, not just the monthly payment. Focus on:
- APR and whether it is promotional or ongoing
- Fees (origination fees, late fees, balance transfer fees)
- Repayment term and how long you will carry the balance
- Budget impact if you need to replace batteries, add a hub, or pay for a subscription
If you are using a credit card and want to understand how interest and payments work, the CFPB’s consumer resources can help you compare costs and avoid surprises: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/.
Frequently asked questions
Do smart locks work during a power outage?
Most smart locks run on batteries, so the lock itself can keep working even if your home power is out. Remote access may not work if your Wi‑Fi router loses power or your internet is down.
Will a smart lock lower my insurance?
Some insurers offer discounts for certain security devices, but it varies by company and policy. If you are considering a smart lock partly for insurance reasons, ask your insurer what devices qualify and what documentation they need.
Should I rekey when I install a smart lock?
If you moved into a new home or do not know who has copies of the old keys, rekeying can be a practical step. If you want all doors on one key, plan rekeying at the same time so you do not pay twice for labor.
How can I reduce the risk of identity theft if I am setting up new accounts?
Use unique passwords and enable multi-factor authentication where available. If you want to review your credit reports for unfamiliar accounts, you can request them at https://www.annualcreditreport.com/.
Bottom line: build a shortlist, then compare the details that affect your daily use
Make your shortlist from recognizable options like Schlage Encode, Schlage Encode Plus, Yale Assure Lock 2, August Wi‑Fi Smart Lock, Level Lock+, Ultraloq U‑Bolt Pro, and Kwikset Halo. Then narrow it by door compatibility, connectivity requirements, access methods, and total cost over time. The “best” choice is usually the one that installs cleanly, works reliably with your ecosystem, and does not add surprise costs after the first week.